Purpose accurately identified, including research question and hypothesis as appropriate.

Criteria/ Possible Points

Content Objectives

Comments

Points Received

Full
Citation –

5
points

Complete
and accurate.

APA
format correct.

Research
Design –

5
points

Correctly
and completely identified.

Introduction
–

10
points

Problem
summary clear and accurate.

Purpose
accurately identified, including research question and hypothesis as
appropriate.

Page
numbers correctly identified and subheadings used.

Methods
–

10
points

Inclusion/exclusion
correct and differentiated appropriately.

Ethical
oversight correctly identified and described.

Measurement
tools clearly and accurately identified.

Page
numbers correctly identified and subheadings used.

Results
–

5
points

Study
N correctly identified.

Data
(findings) reported completely and appropriately based on purpose, question
or hypothesis.

Evident
use of critical thinking.

Page
numbers correctly identified and subheadings used.

Discussion
–

10
points

Clear
identification of important points made by authors regarding current study
results, comparison to prior research, recommendations for future research,
study limitations, study strengths, conclusions. 

Page
numbers correctly identified and subheadings used.

Personal
Application –

5
points

Evident
use of critical thinking for application to own clinical practice.